TLO Restaurant Review: Pickerman’s Soup and Sandwiches
4:00 AM EST on March 9, 2021
When I recently heard that beloved Oklahoma icon BJ Wexler had passed on to that big popcorn machine in the sky, I remembered those times two decades ago when I would usually find him eating alone at a Chinese joint next to Happy Days Record Shop on SW 89th and Penn. I thought it might be fitting to eat there as a tribute to him but, sadly, they were either closed for business or out of business, I was far too dumb to tell.
Still hungry though, my gal-pal Jodie and I stopped at a sandwich shop a few stores away, Pickerman’s Soups and Sandwiches, 8916 S. Penn. While I don’t know if Wexler ever ate there, judging from the old television playing UHF channels in the back, I kind of like to think that he did and that brought something of a comfort to me and my lonely Saturday nights.
Filled with workers and other assorted city employees, we professionally waited in line for our turn to order, studying the wall-mounted board for our well-described choices. Filled with a surprising amount of originality for a sandwich shop, we ordered our eats and sat near that old television as some commercial for economical siding blared at us.
Order ready, I held the bag tightly like an Academy Award as I took out the first sandwich. Absolutely piled with dill slices, the Texas Barbeque ($6.00) on white bread, though admittedly an odd choice for lunchtime, seemed fitting, like a gruff John Wayne flick that should be flickering in the background. With dark red streams of a too-sweet sauce spilling out the sides, the thick chunks of beef were pliable, like a new scoop out of a fresh container of pre-made barbeque that I’ve never heard of.
Jodie’s cup of Baja Chicken Enchilada Soup ($3.00) was very fresh and very delicious, like an edible treasure of the Sierra Madre. But her Chicken Salad Sandwich ($6.00) on wheat, composed of all chicken breast, as well as lettuce and tomatoes, could have been better. Unwrapped, it looked absolutely mouthwatering, but the meat had a slightly sour taste to it that left us both pushing it away; maybe that’s how they do it and I’m an idiot?
Regardless, like a well-cast Dean Martin, I soldiered on to my final sandwich, the traditional That’s Italian ($9.00 for the meal) and, mamma mia, this one’s definitely a keeper! Aided on the side with a helping of macaroni salad, this Italian specialty featured ham and pastrami with a Mediterranean Sea of roasted peppers and provolone cheese on top, capped off with a bit of olive oil. “Abbondanza!” I could hear a glowing blue Wexler gasping loudly with a still-alive Sophia Loren sitting in the chair next to him, enjoying the delicious macaroni salad and giving a small chortle.
As I was continued to dine on that fine concoction, Jodie broke out the Apple Cobbler ($3.00) she picked up for a light dessert and, you know, it was okay, but as I finished the rest of my own macaroni salad, I tried, as close to Heaven as I could, to pay tribute to Wexler and his long-running show; I hope he was somewhat satisfied. Cue the Gremlins theme.
Stay in touch
Sign up for our free newsletter
More from The Lost Ogle
Retail Karen squares off against Social Media “Influencer” at Penn Square Mall…
Who wins this battle of the Internet’s most annoying people?